Murder and Unsolved Mysteries in, The Broken Girls
Murder and Unsolved Mysteries in, The Broken Girls
by Simone St. James
Annotation: An old boarding school holds secrets so dark no one could have fathomed the truth.
Author: Simone St. James
Rating: Mid-Shelf
Popularity: Silver Star
Genre/Subgenre: Adult books for young adults; Ghost stories; Horror; Mysteries; Parallel narratives
Appeal Factors: Haunted house, creepy, compelling
Price: Paperback $7.48, Hardback $12.71, Kindle $9.99, Audible Free with trial as of 12.10.2020
Number of Pages: Hardback 336, Paperback 448, Audiobook 11 hours 12 minutes.
Summary:
Flashing between 1950 and 2014, a mystery unfolds of violence and abuses toward the women of a boarding school. Fiona, a journalist, is looking into the cold case of her own sister's murder when she begins uncovering the dark secrets of the boarding school. Fiona doesn't suspect Deb's boyfriend is the one responsible and a sinister ghostly presence is unsettling for everyone every connected with the school. Many have warned not to go digging on the ground and to leave it be, but stories are turning up as investors, and Fiona, start to dig.
Evaluation:
The premise of this book sounded intriguing, but listening to it just didn't do it justice. I actually preferred the storyline set in the 1950s over the story of Fiona herself in present day. Though we needed Fiona to tell the story.
The book's format was reminiscent of Cindy Lou Who doing her report on the Grinch in Dr. Seuss's How the Grinch Stole Christmas featuring Jim Carrey in Fiona is interviewing everyone she can who was connected with the school and it flashes between then and now.
The book also centers on the mystery surrounding a house, much like, The Haunting of Hill House, but in this book the humans are the scary ones and the evil of humanity is explored.
Unfortunately, while I appreciated the story and it's investigative tone, it didn't keep me engaged like Hill House did. This is a huge reason I struggle with mysteries. Some can keep me locked in but not all.
However, I do think it could make a great movie for Halloween if cast correctly despite the book not being as engaging as expected.
Read-Alikes:
Booktalking Ideas:
Violence and Abuse toward women
Town mysteries and their goal to keep it secret
Teachers and their struggles helping students beyond the classroom
Book Discussion Questions/Ideas:
What were your thoughts on Fiona?
What were your thoughts on Jamie and his family?
What happens to Sonia and why is it significant to the history and the lore surrounding the school?
Who is Mary Hand and why do the girls make up a rhyme?
Why was the teacher so defensive discussing the school?
Why does no one want it touched?
Why does everyone try to warn off Fiona?
What is the significance of the title?
Why would there be a school for troubled girls?
What does the building of the boarding school represent?
Why is the story of each girl told? Why is it relevant to the story?
How did you feel reading the book?
Outside Reviews:
On to Adventure,
Mary Alice






Comments
Post a Comment