Starting Out on Your Own and Finding Home in, Brooklyn
Starting Out on Your Own and Finding Home in, Brooklyn
by Colm Toibin
Annotation: Striking out on her own, Eilis finds success, love, and heartbreak.
Author: Colm Toibin
Rating: Mid-Shelf
Popularity: Silver Star
Genre/Subgenre: Books to movies; Psychological Fiction
Appeal Factors: Immigrant stories, Female lead
Price: Paperback $10.74, Hardback $16.25, Kindle $11.99, Audible Free with trial as of 12/10/2020
Number of Pages: Hardback 262, Paperback 288, Audiobook 7 hours 38 minutes.
Summary:
From a small town in Ireland, Eilis dreams of more. Good with numbers, her priest gets her a job in America and Eilis strikes out on her own. She lives in a boarding house with an eccentric landlady whom she takes pleasure in outsmarting, excels at her job, and falls in love. Her American Dream coming true until a family emergency forces her back to Ireland. But her American secrets find her in Ireland and she must return to Brooklyn, her sense of duty shifting.
Evaluation:
The story is a wonderful telling of a young woman's inner conflict deciding what her life should mean and look like. Eilis encounters a lot, including racism, when she leaves her small town for the big city of New York and this is shown through the people she meets and works with, where she lives, the conversations she has, and even falling in love with an italian man.
Eilis is long dutyful to those she loves, even returning to Ireland upon news her mother was struggling. Potentially staying in Ireland and marrying, her secret of being married in New York before her return catches up to her and her sense of duty shifts and she returns to New York.
I cried, multiple times, reading this. I wanted Eilis to find what she wanted, do what was best for her-whatever that was, Brooklyn or Ireland. I didn't want her to feel stuck.
The story addresses the idea of duty, the motivation to stand up for what is right despite what others think, and that often being the one who is different in the crowd is good thing. As someone who has been the only American in my school and my family the only American in a town, I know the feeling of doing things differently, of not understanding norms, of doing what you know because you don't understand why others would do it any differently. I loved Eilis for this.
Read-Alikes:
Booktalking Ideas:
Young adult life and finding your place
America in the 1950s
Immigration and Immigrant life in America
Book Discussion Questions/Ideas:
How did you feel about Eilis' hometown?
Would you want to leave for a bigger city like Eilis?
How did you feel about Father Flood?
Why did he help Eilis so much?
What was your opinion on the boarding house and its inhabitants?
How did you feel about Eilis' coworkers?
What did you think about Tony?
What was your reaction to her sister dying?
How did Eilis change in Brooklyn?
What did you think of her marrying Tony?
Why did she keep her marriage secret in Ireland?
Did she want to stay in Ireland? Would she have returned to Brooklyn if she wasn't married?
Why was her mom so upset about her returning?
Who do you think she should have been with, Tony or Jim?
Outside Reviews:
On to Adventure,
Mary Alice






Comments
Post a Comment