Big Tops and Big Love Take Center Ring
Introducing, Water for Elephants
by Sara Gruen
Annotation: Big tops and secrets abound as the circus life sustains all classes during The Depression.
Author: Sara Gruen
Rating: Mid-Shelf
Popularity: Gold Star. Published in 2006. Movie released in 2011 keeps it relevant.
Genre/Subgenre: Literary Fiction; Multiple Perspectives; First Person Narrative; Adult Books for Young Adults; Books to Movies
Appeal Factors: Circus; First Person Narrative; The Depression
Price: Paperback $11.55, Hardback $16.18, Kindle $9.04, Audible Free with trial as of (9/20/2020)
Number of Pages: Hardback 350, Paperback 368, Audiobook 11 hours 26 minutes.
Summary:
Water for Elephants, flashes between present day in a nursing home and The Depression era circus over a three months time span. After his family are killed in an accident and he learns all of their possessions will be owned by the bank because his father helped families who couldn't afford to pay him, Jacob jumps a train that just so happens to belong to a circus. When it is discovered he is a veterinarian, Jacob is allowed to stay on. He is introduced to the realities and underhanded tactics of doing business when money is scarce. He falls in love and a murder finally sets them all free.
Evaluation:
This book was enticing from the moment I cracked the spine. The circus is nostalgic and mesmerizing and a book based within its confines is magical even without any magic elements. The way the book bounces between Jacob in his 20s and Jacob in his 90s continues to pull you in and keep the pace of the book going. I'd spend hours reading it.
When real life got in the way, I turned on the audiobook while I put together my virtual classroom. As I read I began to despise certain characters. But I am a sucker for elephants. They are my favorite animals. So I reveled in her as the unsuspecting hereon of the story.
The book touched on racism against Polish families, discrimination against those with disabilities, abuse, and love. It's passionate and considerate. Not quite Top Shelf because some parts just weren't as developed as I would have liked. But definitely one to talk about.
Read-Alikes:
Booktalking Ideas:
Bonds of people and animals
Depression era survival, racism, and discrimination
Caring for the elderly.
Book Discussion Questions/Ideas:
Jacob experiences racism even though he comes from a white, European background; why isn't this recognized more in modern times? Is it still a problem?
Marlena also faces disownment from her family by her choice in husband; why isn't this discussed more in modern times? Do women still face this stigma?
What did the circus represent to Jacob?
What do the elephants represent to Jacob?
How did Jacob change over the course of the story? Both young and elderly?
Outside Reviews:
On to Adventure,
Mary Alice

Comments
Post a Comment